Vanillish

Even a PSA 10 ($53.41) doesn't beat selling raw after grading costs.

50% of the 1,926 copies PSA has graded got a 10. People mostly send their cleanest copies, so a typical raw copy's odds are lower.

Raw (NM)

$4.45

TCGplayer

PSA 10

$53.41

42 sales

PSA 9

$16.59

14 sales

If it misses

$12.93

below 10, by PSA's grades